Share
Liam McDonnell

Liam McDonnell

Policy Researcher at Politheor
Liam McDonnell holds an MSc Environment and Resource Management from the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam which focused on sustainability issues through economic and policy standpoints. Within this program he specialized in sustainable energy analysis and climate policy and holds a particular interest in the flow of goods and services in the economy and their relationship with natural systems and energy infrastructures. He has carried out research internships with Institute for Environmental Studies (IVM) and Institute of Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP) and currently performs stakeholder research for Westminster Forum Projects on upcoming policies and developments involving energy, environment and health in the UK.
Liam McDonnell
Still showing the wounds of the global economic crisis and in the midst of the greatest political minefield of a generation in Brexit, Ireland has sought to address the challenges of climate change with the recent unveiling of the National Mitigation Plan (NMP). However, as the dust has settled, what has become evident is that it is less of an actual action plan and more of a discussion document, tasking questions in the form of “what could be done” rather than “how they can be done”. The lack of bite in the document drew a not unexpected collective sigh of disappointment from the environmental community.

Ireland

Ireland has a low population density and an abundance of good land and marine territory available for renewable energy potential meaning that in terms of pure technical capacity it could be a climate leader, yet it has rightfully earned the reputation as a climate laggard. More than 90% of Ireland’s energy is from fossil fuels, including electricity from a large coal and peat burning power stations (peat being an even more carbon-dense fuel source than coal). Per capita, Ireland’s emissions are the third highest in Europe effectively resulting in the forfeiture of achieving 2020 targets (2015) – 13.49 Tonnes of CO2 equivalent per capita in Ireland compared to 8.28 Tonnes in the UK.

The relationship between Irish state, its people, and climate change is a frivolous case. For a nation gifted with scenic beauty environmental issues remain low in priority of public opinion as a whole and in the wake of the Irish economic crisis that had unfolded in 2008 attention has fallen further.

Ireland does have an active and hardworking environmental sector but the fact is that it’s simply underfunded and under-resourced and with the reality of Brexit beckoning we may once again see environmental issues become an afterthought. The last two decades have included much talk about decarburization but little in the way of action by successive governments; in fact, Ireland only reached targets set by the Kyoto Protocol due to reduced production from the economic downtown.

At the unveiling of the NMP, the Irish Prime Minister Taoiseach Leo Varadkar professed that the climate crisis would require a fundamental societal transformation and an “all government approach”. Although this certainly contains the right sentiment and seems to appreciate the gravitas of the situation an attempt was also made to defend its lackadaisical ambition level by describing it as the “first step”.

Considering the omission of concrete targets and actions the plan has rightfully drawn wide criticism, most notably from the independent Irish advisory body the Climate Change Advisory Council, essentially the NMP contains rhetoric that was needed 10 years ago and runs amiss by today’s standards.

A survey carried by Sustainable Energy Ireland (SEAI) in 2015 found just 49% of the Irish population believes climate change is a major problem. Interestingly the same survey also discovered that 53% of citizens recognized their role in tackling climate change as more important than businesses, environmental groups, and local authorities. Regarding energy security and dependency on imports 77% said they would favor the development of renewables and research into new technologies.

These figures may seem contradictory in part but they demonstrate the mindset of Ireland. The people, in general, understand the risks climate change possesses in terms of economic self-preservation, meaning that they recognize that an energy transition is something that is needed for future economic prosperity yet they still limp when it comes to action.

The attitude to overall emissions, however, takes on a naive tone; climate change is seen as a global problem and something that the small Emerald Isle has no real control over, therefore short-term costs are met with grave resistance and often perpetrates the “not in my backyard” attitude.

Perhaps it is no wonder that Ireland is slow on the uptake of substantial climate policy. Traditionally Ireland is an agricultural economy and this sector alone contributes over 33% to national emissions. Political parties agree that agriculture should be granted special considerations, an expected standpoint considering political capital involved. Yet this protectionist policy is untenable and only serves to undermine the sector for the next generation, both in terms of adaptation to the physical environmental changes and the prospect of future stricter EU policies.

An optimistic person would see the NMP as a welcomed change in approach by the government but the fact is that Ireland is playing catch up and still has no tangible direction towards decarbonization.

Furthermore, there is a focus on minimizing the short-term costs instead of taking into account effects of failure to take immediate action, basically looking at it as “cost” instead of “investment”.

Ireland is at a crossroads, does it continue to warrant the label of climate laggard or does it start to do its fair share? The NMP is a weak document and would be significantly strengthened if it included actual policies such as;

  • Ending peat subsidies for electricity generation
  • Phasing out of fossil fuels in transport
  • Higher carbon taxes
  • Grants for retrofitting building stock to near-zero emission levels
  • Adoption of a comprehensive land use strategy for agriculture

Whether this is truly the first step remains to be seen, as it stands the NMP presents a missed opportunity and seems to be an attempt to conform to EU values without taking concrete steps.

What is clear is that Brexit will continue to dominate the headlines and concerns in Ireland but in doing so environmental issues and climate policy must not become a silent casualty. The Irish need to deconstruct the notion that environmental ambition is at the expense of economic growth and recognize the opportunity it may present whilst being acutely aware of risks involved with inaction.

In a week of devastating hurricanes and extreme weather man’s submission to Mother Nature is no more evident.  Ireland like many countries has to step up and do its fair share, if not for the ethical and moral standpoint then at least for matters self-preservation and prosperity.

Tags: , ,

Liam McDonnell
Liam McDonnell holds an MSc Environment and Resource Management from the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam which focused on sustainability issues through economic and policy standpoints. Within this program he specialized in sustainable energy analysis and climate policy and holds a particular interest in the flow of goods and services in the economy and their relationship with natural systems and energy infrastructures. He has carried out research internships with Institute for Environmental Studies (IVM) and Institute of Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP) and currently performs stakeholder research for Westminster Forum Projects on upcoming policies and developments involving energy, environment and health in the UK.

5 Responses to “Ireland Continues to limp towards its Climate Commitments – Unwilling or Unable to Comply?” Subscribe

  1. Elaine 20/09/2017 at 10:18 pm #

    Hi Liam
    I’m not normally one to read these type of articles nor am I one to comment on articles i do read however I’ve made an exception with this one on the basis that I found it very interesting and more importantly inciteful into what’s going on in our country. It’s very well worded and more importantly it does not solely target those that are aware of the situation, rather it’s understandable and makes sense to the normal folk who happen to stumble across the article.
    Very well executed.
    Elaine

  2. Lacey 30/09/2017 at 11:24 am #

    Good selection of an important topic of discussion in the climate change arena. The role of Ireland as a state tackling their own input to climate change as a whole is crucial moving forward and prompting questions of their response and tactics is a smart choice indeed. Would be interesting and useful to delve more into the behavioral aspect of their resistance to make positive changes.

  3. Alison 30/09/2017 at 4:09 pm #

    Reiterating the previous comments, I really enjoyed this article. I thought it articulated and gave insight into some of the major concerns for Ireland’s policies (or lack of) on climate change mitigation. Definitely agree that the rhetoric of decarbonisation being seen as a cost rather than an investment is something that still needs to be changed across many countries, if real progress is to be made. This is especially true for agriculture and land use policy. Nice work, look forward to reading more articles on the topic.

  4. James 01/10/2017 at 11:00 am #

    Interesting read Liam,

    I can certainly resonate with your view point about Ireland’s preparations or lack of anticipation for climate control measures. Especially when the NMP has been outlining measures that will only lay the foundations for transitioning Ireland to a low carbon, climate resilient and environmentally sustainable economy by 2050, (33 years away). I do not like to see the figures or percentages that SEAI release on there surveys as I always feel they do not cover enough of the population in with the questions, and for Ireland being such a low population the percentage look worse than they might actually truly be, if the majority of the nation have not been surveyed.

    I am interested in your point on the adoption of the comprehensive land use strategy for agriculture and how you think this should be implemented yourself. You do seem well educated and up to date on the Irelands lack of efforts towards climate change and decabonization, and I would like to hear a more fleshed out plan of action for the points you mentioned that should be focused in on. Instead of the NMP merely outlining a first step approach dead lining Ireland’s status as “doing their fair share” enough by 2050 we definitely should be hearing a more strategical plan being enforced.

    Good insight to the current position we are in as a nation and our responsibility’s towards the impact on the planet, hope to read more from you in the future. Best of luck.

  5. Tiki Zlamal 01/10/2017 at 9:51 pm #

    Seems short term planning is stunting any innovation in Ireland. With big events in the near future, it dosnt seem Ireland will break this cycle

Leave a Reply

*