The Devil’s Duplicates: The trouble twins of Madagascar

The Devil’s Duplicates: The trouble twins of Madagascar

You might be surprised to learn that the village of Mananjary in Madagascar believes its twins are cursed and carry misfortune.

In the 21st century, while the world progresses, Mananjary lies deep in the clutches of this age-old tradition where twins are a malediction. When born these are abandoned and left to die. This bizarre and barbaric taboo makes the Antambahoaka tribe one of the most perplexing in the world in a place where these ancestral traditions form the core of the social structure. The Antambahoaka twins seem to be the only ones in the world to be ostracized by a community and recklessly left at birth.

The twin taboo that is stronger than the bond of a mother and child is baffling. The Antambahoaka believe that their forefathers live among them and that a dead ancestor grows stronger as time goes. Thus, venerating them by observing such traditions is the social custom. Twins are cursed and one such example is almost three centuries old. Also, a legend from Madagascar’s 1947 revolt against the French has it that a  Queen from this tribe had forgotten one of her twins while fleeing the war. When the soldiers went back to bring the child, they were all killed. The village elders blamed the failure of this revolt on her twins.

Still today, fears of being cursed by ancestors, compel mothers to abandon their twins or leave the village. One such story is the one of Carolin, mother of three sets of twins. She now lives as an outcast after her husband and family rejected them. The tribe believes in their ancestral King Raminia Rabevahoaka and trusts ancient monarchial systems. Local kings of the tribe exert authority and act as the royal guardians. Despite multiple negotiations between local authorities and the kings, this familial cultural tradition stands strong. Almost 70.7% of Madagascar’s population lives in poverty and are largely illiterate. A reason the tribe is steeped in superstitions and traditions that defy the dignity of human existence.

Twins form only 2.8% of the births in Madagascar. However, in these dark clouds, the village of Fanavela holds a silver lining. Since 1982, this village has found a way to nurture its twins. Although a superstitious practice, they offer the sacrifice of cows to appease the Gods to rid themselves of this inhumane curse. The village King also regularly invites all village children including twins, to his home.

In 2007, the Government finally came around to recognize this situation as a burning issue. The Madagascar Constitution does not prohibit torture and ill-treatment of children. Killing of children is against the national law, but this superstition still persists. The Madagascar Government is respectful of the tribe’s culture and hence does not take counter measures. Madagascar has a special law which states that parents cannot reject their children. However, the situation on the ground is complex. As customs seem to override the law. The twin separation custom is based on a historical misperception and violates the rights of children and mothers.

The issue however, is more complicated once it is also a taboo to discuss a taboo. The existing laws need to be backed by outreach efforts, especially by people from NGOs that take care of abandoned twins as – Catja Orphanage, Fanatenane. Greater engagement from individuals, families and communities at the local levels is necessary. Advocacy and capacity development will take place only when tribesmen find it safe to discuss the situation The Government can invite Human Rights Defenders and facilitators who are skilled to sensitively address the twin taboo. Any change needed in a cultural setting cannot be imposed externally, but has to come from within. For example, the Government may start a national and international media partnership/campaign to build capacity for child-friendly journalism. The youth may also be targeted by introducing programs in schools that will spread awareness about the adverse effects of this belief.

Finally, the people from Fanavela and Mananjary can come together and discuss how to address this stigma. Positive values exist in every culture and there is a clear need for communities to work together and fight these traditions. Spreading education and literacy will go miles in redressing this human subject. Will the Antambahoaka community have the political will to learn from the lessons of Fanavela and carry them even further?


Posts Carousel

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *


  • Saptarshi Gupta
    30/01/2019, 2:47 am

    Very well written article. I cannot believe such a custom mentioned in the article it must first stop being a taboo to even be open to discussions on this issue…hope things improve in the future.

    • Oleena Chaudhuri@Saptarshi Gupta
      02/03/2019, 6:38 pm

      Thank you very much for the comment! Hope for the same too. It is difficult but certainly not impossible.

  • mita ghosh
    01/02/2019, 3:09 pm

    A concise article covering the problem with suggestions on remedial action.
    As pointed out, the deep-rooted belief of the natives of the discussed area is the direct product of poverty,lack of education and exposure to the outer world.The Rulers/Guardians of these Society also never bothered to challenge and win over the superstitions; probably because of their own illiteracy and the fear of losing control.Government action supported by the NGOs can go a long way in erasing this social stigma.

    • Oleena Chaudhuri@mita ghosh
      02/03/2019, 6:40 pm

      Absolutely! Well analysed. Appreciate you sparing time to give it a read and for commenting. Really hope the stigma disappears.

  • Anonymous
    07/05/2019, 8:32 pm

    In depth analysis of an issue that is not so known.

  • Leanne Adams
    29/04/2020, 8:18 am

    Please tell me where and how to send finance donations to the abandoned twins orphanage! I’m from America and would like to help

    • Dr. Kajuana Farrey@Leanne Adams
      10/07/2020, 4:10 am

      I would like to adopt a set of twins how can I do thos

    • Charlene Jenkins @Leanne Adams
      30/11/2020, 2:53 pm

      I would like to donate to the orphanage and to the village where the mothers live with their babies. Should we expect to see an updated episode now that the story has been made known?

  • Anonymous
    23/08/2020, 6:22 am

    I still do not understand or know what the real reason for doing something like this. It could be one of those things where we have been doing something for so long that we do not question why we are doing it. If you know what I mean.

    • Pray Daily@Anonymous
      24/12/2020, 12:24 am

      Yes they do what is acceptable and give into peer pressure..just like if I dont do traditional "Christmas" I’m ousted from family and looked down on b.c. they dont understand why I dont think santa (satan backwards) is worthy to be worshipped.
      I understand you only know what ya you’ve been taught…and how you know it.
      So if it always that way then how can ya change it…even if lives are at stake.
      My heart ❤ aches for these precious souls who don’t know any better.
      Pray Daily
      Replied 12.23.2020 @ 6:22pm


Latest Posts

Top Authors

More authors